"It does not require a majority to prevail, but rather an irate, tireless minority keen to set brush fires in people's minds." Samuel Adams

Sunday, October 26, 2008

The de Tocqueville Dictum

When a young college student tells Barack Obama how she is struggling to pay for her college education, instead of commending her for her industry and hard work, and telling her how much the experience will benefit her for the rest of her life, he tells her that when he becomes president, he will help her out (i.e. a $4000.00 tax credit for college tuition, which presumably means a person must owe at least that much in taxes, but with Obama who knows?). This is the fulfillment, right before our eyes, of the de Tocqueville Dictum, which states, "The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public's money" (Alexis de Tocqueville). What Obama is telling this young woman is that he will take some of the hard-earned money of her friends and family members and give it to her to help cover the cost of education. He calls this fairness. I call it legalized theft and/or the redistribution of wealth and/or pandering to the "what's in it for me?" spirit. Or as de Tocqueville so insightfully called it over 150 years ago: bribing the public with the public's money. Once the de Tocqueville Dictum has become the standard political currency of the day, is it possible for a nation to ever go back? I am beginning to doubt it.

2 comments:

Bill said...

You're absolutely right; the strength of America was that voters for generations have understood the implicit power to realize the de Tocqueville Dictum, but have udnerstood the greater power of the American ideal - a system in which hard work, self-reliance, industry, and good citizenshiop is rewarded. For generations, voters have understood that the short term gratifications to be won via the de Tocqueville Dictum come at the expense of long-term prosperity, stability, and opportunity.

Today, of course, in this age of instant gratification, the event horizon for most voters' consciousness is about two weeks.

Brian C. Caffrey said...

Not without a revolution, we can't get back, Dave. We're going to need a lot of revolutionaries.